Argentinian football: miracle or mere coincidence?

Argentina. A country that has given the world two of the greatest footballers of all time, has won world championships at intervals of decades, experienced grand failures and inexplicable rises. For some, Argentinian football is magic, mysticism, and divine providence. For others, it is dry statistics, a lucky calendar, and luck with talent. Where is the truth? Let's try to figure it out without falling into extremes, but by looking at the phenomenon under a microscope of history, sociology, and pure chance.

Roots: not just a game, but a way of survival

Unlike Europe, where football long remained an aristocratic pastime, it came to Argentina with English sailors and railway workers at the end of the 19th century. But here the game quickly descended into port districts and poor neighborhoods. For immigrants from Italy, Spain, Germany, and Eastern European countries, football became not a pastime, but a social elevator and a way to prove their right to exist in a foreign land.

Street fields, called \"potrero,\" were asphalt patches where the ball jumped over bumps, and goals were piles of stones or backpacks. It was there that the \"Argentinian style\" was born — low center of gravity, deceptive movements of the body, non-standard striking technique. These skills were not learned in training, but forged in constant improvised battles, where every match was a war for survival. Coincidence? Perhaps, but it was necessity, born of poverty and the absence of normal stadiums.

But the miracles begin when this street school suddenly coincides with a genetic mixture that gives unique plasticity. An Argentinian is a European with African and indigenous admixture, and this cocktail has given football incredible coordination and explosive power. Can it be called a miracle? More likely, a winning combination of migratory flows that no one planned.

Tactical anarchy and geniuses without training

Argentina long did not have its own clearly defined tactical school, unlike Brazil or Uruguay. Here, the cult of individuality reigned. Every player was allowed to improvise, and coaches were more like psychologists than tacticians. This led to chaos on the field, but in this chaos, stars were born who could decide an episode alone.

Take, for example, the \"golden era\" of the 1940s, when \"River Plate\" performed miracles with the \"La Máquina\" team — Di Stefano, Moreno, Pedernera... This was a coincidence of talents, but also a lucky coincidence: Argentina's economic boom allowed the best players to stay in the country. However, in the 1950s, when wealth disappeared, football did not disappear — it simply went deeper, into the provinces, into the poorest clubs. It was there, away from the capital's glitter, that new geniuses matured, who were then taken to Europe.

This seems like a natural phenomenon: a country the size of a third of Europe, with a population of 40 million, produces more talents than all of Western Europe combined. They say, \"In Argentina, the ball grows on trees.\" But if it was purely a miracle, then neighboring countries would also give as much. However, Paraguayans, Chileans, and Bolivians do not have such a constellation. Therefore, there is something special in culture, mentality, and how they live and cheer here.

Passion as a catalyst: politics and football in one harness

It is impossible to consider Argentinian football in isolation from the country's history. Dictatorship, \"dirty war,\" the loss of 30,000 people, economic crises — all this found its outlet on the stadiums. In 1978, the country hosted the World Cup under the auspices of a military junta. Victory was needed by the regime as an ideological trump card, and it happened — with controversial refereeing decisions and not without the help of the \"home field advantage.\" Is this not a coincidence? But at the same time, the team played with such passion that any doubts about the honesty of the players faded before their self-sacrifice.

Maradona became a national hero in 1986 not only because of the \"Hand of God\" but also because his victory over England in the quarterfinals was seen as a historical revenge for the Falklands War. Again, football turned into a battlefield of spirit. Miracle? Perhaps, but a miracle prepared over years of hatred and humiliation. Without context, that war, that goal with the hand would never have become legendary. So here it's 50-50 — and divine spark, and malicious irony of fate.

Defeats as the foundation for new victories

If you look at the statistics, Argentina has lost almost as many finals as it has won. Three consecutive Copa America finals (2004, 2007, 2015) and three World Cup finals (1930, 1978? no, 1930, 1990, 2014). But it is precisely defeats that toughen character. The famous \"cry\" of Messi after three consecutive finals losses with the national team was a cry of the soul that later turned into champion maturity.

Is it a coincidence that Messi and Maradona were born in Argentina, not in some other country? Of course, chance, but at the same time — a high density of talent, competition, and constant selection. In Argentina, football is a religion, and parents send their children to academies at the age of three. The \"feverish\" search for new stars works continuously, and sooner or later any super-talent does not go unnoticed. This is no longer a miracle, but a technology, albeit informal.

Take, for example, the generation of the 2000s, when the national team could not win anything, but regularly reached the semifinals. Experts believed that this was a \"team without spirit.\" But in 2021, the Copa America came, then the Finalissima, and then the World Cup in Qatar. This series is associated with the arrival of coach Scaloni, who, in essence, was a \"random\" choice — he was appointed after a failure, and no one believed in success. And this \"random\" coach built the perfect balance between stars and workers, between attack and defense. So what is it — a miracle of hiring a specialist or a coincidence when all the pieces fell into place?

Argentinian character: all or nothing

One of the main factors is the psychological setup. Argentinians play with extreme aggression, with a desire to morally destroy the opponent. This is not the European pragmatic craft, but an art with a touch of madness. They are ready to take risks, even if it threatens failure. It is precisely because of this that they often lose their heads in key matches, but it is precisely because of this that they are able to make comebacks that no one can explain with logic.

Remember the semi-final against the Netherlands in 2022 — after scoring 2:0, they allowed the Dutch to equalize in the last seconds, but then won on penalties. Was this a coincidence of nervous breakdowns? Yes. A miracle of goalkeeper Martínez? Also. But this is the essence of Argentinian football — it exists on the edge of the foul, on the edge of madness, and every match is like a serial with an unpredictable ending.

The same drama happened in the final against Germany in 1986, when Argentina led 2:0, allowed the Germans to equalize, and then scored the winning goal in the last minute. These roller coaster rides cannot be withstand by any tactical scheme. This is pure emotion, transmitted from the stands to the players. Fans in Argentina are the 12th player who can crush with whistles or lift to the heavens. And this energy connection is also a kind of coincidence of historical, cultural, and social circumstances.

Influence of Italian and Spanish roots

It is impossible to forget that 60% of Argentinians have Italian roots, and 30% have Spanish roots. The tactical school of Italy taught the ability to defend, while Spain taught short passing. In Argentina, this symbiosis gave a hybrid: defense like the Italians, but attack like street hooligans from the boulevard. This was manifested in the game of Di Stefano, who could play on any position, and Kempes, who scored with both feet. Then this was passed on to Maradona, and from him to Messi.

You can say that this is not a miracle, but an inherited trait passed down through generations. But why is it that there are not so many geniuses born in Italy? Because in Italy, football is more structured, regulated, while in Argentina — chaotic, and it is chaos that gives rise to non-standard decisions. So this is a coincidence of cultures that gave a unique phenotype.

Economic factor: crisis as a driving force

Paradox: economic difficulties stimulate football exports. Young players understand that only through football can they get out of poverty, and therefore are ready to work hard. European clubs buy Argentinian talents in bulk, and they adapt quickly because they are accustomed to fighting from childhood. This is not a miracle, but a harsh calculation. But the fact that among these thousands of \"sellable\" players, some suddenly become idols — this is already an element of chance, a lottery that cannot be planned.

Take, for example, \"Ajax\" or \"Barcelona\" — they built schools according to Argentinian models, but a complete copy was not possible. Because in Europe there is no such street school where ten teenagers kick the ball in the mud until dark, without a coach, without rules. And this is already more a miracle than a calculation. This is an atmosphere that cannot be created artificially.

The national team as a reflection of the nation: unity in chaos

In recent years, we have seen a clear trend: the Argentina national team has become more united than ever. Before, there were groups, \"Messi's gang\" and \"Aguero's gang,\" disagreements with coaches. But since 2019, the team has turned into a collective of like-minded people. This was made possible by the efforts of Scaloni and Messi's leadership qualities, who stopped being a silent genius and became a real captain.

Is it a coincidence that Messi finally waited for a generation that did not hinder him, but helped? Perhaps, yes. But he himself has also changed, learned to take responsibility at the level of the entire team. And when in the final of 2022 Mbappé equalized the score, Argentina did not break, as it used to be. They showed a steel character. Miracle? Or the result of the hard work of psychologists and coaches? Both.

Comparison with the Brazilian phenomenon

Brazil also has a rich history and geniuses, but its football is a dance, a carnival, joy. Argentinian football is a drama, pain, struggle, and at the same time triumph. Brazilians play for the audience, Argentinians — for victory at any cost. Maybe that's why they have fewer titles, but each title is fought for to the last drop of blood. And this is not by chance: climate, history, mentality — all this works to create such a style.

If we consider it as a coincidence, then we can say that Argentina simply had good luck with geography and historical traumas that made football a psychotherapy for the nation. And if as a miracle — then it lies in the fact that despite all the hardships and crises, this country continues to win the hearts of billions of fans with its unyielding football.

In conclusion: the synthesis of two beginnings

Perhaps Argentinian football is not pure miracle and not just a coincidence. It is a complex cocktail where 40% are natural data and historical roots, 40% are social conditions and culture, and 20% are that very spark that cannot be explained by science. We can sort out genetics, children's playgrounds, economic incentives, tactical errors, and lucky calendars. But there will be some residue, inexplicable, like Maradona's hand goal or Messi's pass through the entire defense of \"Hetafe\".

And perhaps, this is the main beauty of football: it leaves room for believing in miracles, even if you know all the numbers and facts. Argentina is the best example of this. It teaches us that in sports, as in life, calculation, inspiration, and a bit of luck are important. Without calculation, you can't win a tournament, without a miracle, you won't be remembered for centuries. The Argentinians know how to combine both, and that's why their football is eternal.

So, to answer the question in the title, we say: Argentinian football is both a miracle and a coincidence, intertwined in such a tight knot that trying to break it only confirms their inseparability. And this is its eternal riddle, which we will be solving for many years to come, but we are unlikely to ever solve it completely.
© elibrary.org.uk

Permanent link to this publication: